What the National Popular Vote Compact teaches business owners about trigger clauses, blackout periods, and the consent nobody got
On November 3, most of the country watched to see which party took control of Congress and the statehouses. Lost in the coverage is a potential change in how future presidents will be elected.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact was proposed twenty years ago, in 2006, as an agreement under which states pledge their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote. It does nothing until the member states together hold 270 electoral votes, a majority of the Electoral College, and has been stuck short of the finish line ever since. After last week, that could change.
Whether that's a good idea is a political question, and you can make up your own mind about it. This post is about the agreement itself. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a contract. It has a trigger, a measurement date, a lockup, a data-reliance clause, and one very large open question about consent. If you've ever signed a SAFE, a shareholder agreement, or a term sheet, you'll recognize every one of these terms.
What happened
As of this writing, 18 states and the District of Columbia have enacted Compact, totaling 222 electoral votes. Virginia was the most recent to join, in 2026, leaving the compact 48 votes short.
The midterms changed who controls the states that could close that gap. Democrats won the governorship and both legislative chambers in five states that haven't joined: Pennsylvania (19 electoral votes), Michigan (15), Arizona (11), Wisconsin (10), and Nevada (6). That's 61 votes. If all five joined, the compact would reach 283. Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Arizona alone would get it to 267, three short.
Pennsylvania is the biggest single piece. Governor Josh Shapiro has reaffirmed his support for electing presidents by national popular vote and said he'll work with lawmakers on the right mechanism, without committing to the compact bill itself. State Rep. Heather Boyd has said she plans to introduce it next session. The idea has had cross-party sponsors before: a 2024 Pennsylvania House bill (HB 2662) was co-sponsored by two Democrats and two Republicans.
Supporters argue that the candidate with the most votes should win, and that winner-take-all rules focus presidential campaigns on a handful of swing states. Opponents argue that the Electoral College protects the role of the states, smaller states in particular, and that changing how the president is chosen should go through a constitutional amendment, not a side agreement. Both arguments have serious people behind them.
A brief history of the Electoral College
The Constitution never uses the words "Electoral College." Article II says only that each state "shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors" equal to its number of senators and representatives. The electors meet in their own states and vote, and under the Twelfth Amendment a candidate needs a majority of them to win. The rest of what most people think of as the Electoral College, including the statewide popular vote and winner-take-all, comes from state law.
Delegation to the states was a deliberate choice. The 1787 Constitutional Convention assumed Congress would pick the president. That idea lost ground over the summer because a president chosen by Congress would owe his job to Congress. Pennsylvania's James Wilson proposed letting the people elect the president directly. Direct election lost too because delegates worried about voters judging candidates from distant states, about large states overpowering small ones, and about keeping the states involved in the new federal government.
The final language came out of a committee in early September. The committee left the method for selecting and delegating electors to each state's legislature.
States used that freedom immediately. In the first presidential election, voters chose the electors in only six states; elsewhere, legislatures picked them directly. Winner-take-all wasn't in the Constitution or even discussed at the Convention. It spread state by state in the early 1800s, largely because a state that split its electors lost influence to states that voted as a bloc. The Supreme Court has consistently backed this discretion, describing the legislatures' power as "plenary" in 1892 and holding in 2020 that states can require electors to vote as pledged.
Seen against that history, the compact is not an unusual move. It is one more "Manner" a legislature can direct, using the same power that produced winner-take-all. Whether states can use that power together, by binding agreement, is a separate question discussed below.
Now let's read the contract.
The Everyday Millionaires Series
At Nerd Lawyer, “we believe in humans.”
Choosing a president runs on rules. So does starting a business: licenses, permits, and regulations that stand between a good idea and a working company. Our Everyday Millionaires post looks at how everyday founders get past them. Next week’s series digs into the rules that could affect your next venture and what you can do about them. Subscribe, and we’ll send each piece as it publishes.
New posts in the series, delivered as they publish. Unsubscribe anytime. This is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Reading it like a contract
The full text of the compact is 888 words. That's shorter than most NDAs. Here's what's in it.
1. The trigger: nothing happens until 270
"This agreement shall take effect when states cumulatively possessing a majority of the electoral votes have enacted this agreement in substantially the same form and the enactments by such states have taken effect in each state."
This is a condition precedent, and it's carefully built. Passing a bill isn't enough. Each state's law has to be in substantially the same form, and it has to have actually taken effect under that state's own rules. A signed-but-not-yet-effective law doesn't count.
Business owners see this structure all the time. A SAFE converts on a qualified equity financing, and the definition of "qualified" decides when you're bound. A drag-along kicks in at a stated percentage of holders. The trigger is usually the most negotiated sentence in the document, because it decides whether anything else in the document matters.
2. "Effective" is not the same as "operative"
The trigger above makes the compact effective once. A separate clause decides whether it controls a particular election:
"This article shall govern the appointment of presidential electors in each member state in any year in which this agreement is, on July 20, in effect in states cumulatively possessing a majority of the electoral votes."
That's a measurement date. The compact can be in force and still not apply to an election, if the members fall below 270 on July 20 of that year. That could happen through withdrawals or a change in electoral vote counts after a census.
For 2028, this is the date that matters. New member states would need their laws not just passed but in effect by July 20, 2028.
The startup version: a convertible note can sit on your cap table for years and never convert. A financial covenant is tested on a specific date, not continuously. Know which of your obligations are triggered once and which are re-tested.
3. The blackout: you can leave, just not mid-game
"Any member state may withdraw from this agreement, except that a withdrawal occurring six months or less before the end of a President's term shall not become effective until a President or Vice President shall have been qualified to serve the next term."
In practice, that's a blackout from July 20 of an election year until the inauguration. A state that wants out after seeing the polls can pass a repeal, but the repeal won't take effect until the election cycle is over.
This is a lockup. It's the same logic as a no-shop period in an acquisition or a notice period for terminating a key supply contract. The exit right exists, but the drafter has blocked it at the moment when using it would do the most damage to everyone else.
4. Relying on numbers you don't control
Under the compact, each member state's election official adds up the popular vote from every state, including states that never joined. Each member must treat other states' official final counts as conclusive if they're certified by the federal deadline.
In other words, a member state agrees in advance that its electors will be chosen partly by vote counts from states that aren't parties to the agreement and owe it nothing.
If you've negotiated an earnout or a revenue-share deal, you've faced this problem. Say you sell your SaaS company and $2 million of the price is an earnout, paid only if your product does $5 million in revenue in the first year after closing. After closing, the buyer decides how to recognize multi-year contracts, whether your product gets bundled into its enterprise suite at a discount, and how much of its own overhead gets charged against your numbers. You can hit the target by your own count and miss it by theirs. Your payment depends on numbers in someone else's books. The fix is the same one the compact uses: agree up front whose numbers are final, and by what date.
5. The cleanup clauses
The compact also has a tie-breaker (in a national tie, each member state falls back to its own statewide winner), a severability clause, and an automatic termination if the Electoral College is abolished. These read like boilerplate. They aren't. Each one answers a "what if" that would otherwise be decided by a court in a hurry.
6. What's missing: consent
Here's the red flag.
The Constitution's Compact Clause (Article I, Section 10) says no state shall, "without the Consent of Congress," enter into "any Agreement or Compact with another State." The compact's text doesn't mention Congress at all. Most of the debate isn't about whether Pennsylvania, acting alone, could award its electors to the national popular vote winner. As the history above shows, Article II leaves that choice to each legislature. The question is whether states can do it together, through a binding agreement, without Congress.
Whether that matters is one of the most debated questions in election law.
Critics argue that it matters a great deal. The Cato Institute has called the compact an unconstitutional effort to nullify the Electoral College. The Heritage Foundation argues that it's unconstitutional without congressional consent. Election law scholar Derek Muller, who has written on the question for years, argues that the compact likely requires consent and that recent Supreme Court decisions seem to lean in that direction.
Proponents argue that it doesn't. Under the Supreme Court's long-standing approach, interstate agreements only need consent if they increase state power at the expense of federal supremacy. Groups like FairVote argue that the compact uses a power the Constitution already gives each state (choosing how to appoint its electors) and doesn't change any non-member state's rights. National Popular Vote, the group behind the compact, points out that no court has ever struck down an interstate agreement for lack of congressional consent. For example, the Court upheld the Multistate Tax Compact, which member states had put into effect after Congress failed to approve it, reasoning that the compact gave states no powers they couldn't exercise on their own. It has also upheld reciprocal state banking laws that operated without congressional consent.
Critics answer that the comparison has limits. When the Court upheld the Multistate Tax Compact, it emphasized that member states could withdraw at any time, and it rejected claims that the compact harmed non-member states. The popular vote compact limits withdrawal during its blackout period, and critics argue it would effectively decide the presidency for non-member states without their agreement.
There's also a timing problem. Because the compact has never taken effect, no court has ruled on it, and experts generally expect that a challenge can't be brought until the compact actually reaches 270. If that happens in 2027 or 2028, the litigation could run right up against, or past, a presidential election.
Congress could settle the question by consenting. Proponents say that's unnecessary, and whether it would happen depends on who controls Congress at the time.
Business owners know this pattern. A deal looks done until diligence finds a key contract with a change-of-control clause nobody triggered, or an equity grant that the board never approved. The deal usually still closes, but now on someone else's timeline and at a price. The compact has the same exposure, with one difference: there's no way to get a ruling before closing.
Why this matters for your company
Read your agreement. Somewhere in your stack there's a conversion trigger, a measurement date, a lockup or notice period, a payment based on someone else's numbers, and at least one approval that should exist but might not. The questions are the same we just asked of the compact. What triggers this? When is it measured? Who can leave, and when? Whose numbers count? Did everyone who needed to consent actually consent?
Plan for uncertainty you can't control. If the compact reaches 270, a legal fight over the 2028 election rules is likely to follow, possibly close to the election itself. Nobody can tell you how that ends. What you can control is your own house: clean records, documented approvals, and contracts that say what happens when things get unpredictable. Companies with their paperwork in order handle outside volatility better than companies discovering gaps in the middle of it.
You don't have to have a view on the Electoral College to take the lesson. The people who drafted this compact thought hard about triggers, timing, and exits. The open question that could still sink it is a consent nobody secured in advance. That's true of a lot of startups too.
If you want someone to read your company's contracts the way we just read this one, start with the Investor Readiness Vault at nerdlawyer.ai.
Curt Wadsworth, J.D., Ph.D. is the founder of Nerd Lawyer Entrepreneur Services, an AI-native corporate and IP law firm serving founders, startups, SMBs, and growth-stage companies. Reach him at curt@nerdlawyer.ai.
This post is for general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Nerd Lawyer Entrepreneur Services, 901 Western Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15233.
Sources
Text of the National Popular Vote Compact, National Popular Vote
McPherson v. Blacker, 146 U.S. 1 (1892)
Virginia v. Tennessee, 148 U.S. 503 (1893)
United States Steel Corp. v. Multistate Tax Commission, 434 U.S. 452 (1978)
Northeast Bancorp, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 472 U.S. 159 (1985)
Chiafalo v. Washington, 591 U.S. 578 (2020)
Overview of Electors Appointment Clause, Constitution Annotated (Cornell LII)
Discretion of Electors in Choosing a President, Constitution Annotated (Cornell LII)
Strange Political Bedfellows, History News Network
Sean Wilentz, "The Electoral College Was Not a Pro-Slavery Ploy," New York Times (April 2019)
Akhil Reed Amar, "Actually, the Electoral College Was a Pro-Slavery Ploy," New York Times (April 2019)
What Is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact?, ElectoralVoteMap (updated Nov. 6, 2026)
Democrats' midterm gains could sideline Electoral College by 2028, Axios (Nov. 4, 2026)
Pennsylvania's Democratic trifecta renews calls to join National Popular Vote compact, Pennsylvania Capital-Star
Democrats win control of Arizona House, Senate and Governor's Office for the first time in 60 years, KJZZ (Nov. 6, 2026)
Pennsylvania bill history, National Popular Vote
The Unconstitutional Compact to Nullify the Electoral College, Cato Institute (Fall 2026)
The National Popular Vote: Misusing an Interstate Compact to Bypass the Constitution, Heritage Foundation (2020)
Supreme Court's developing Compact Clause jurisprudence may affect National Popular Vote, Derek Muller, Election Law Blog
Dispelling the Major Legal Arguments Against the National Popular Vote Compact, FairVote
Shapiro calls for 'significant change' in Washington as Democrats look toward 2028, FOX43 (Nov. 8, 2026)
© 2026 Nerd Lawyer Entrepreneur Services. All rights reserved.